16th Annual Writer’s Digest International SELF-PUBLISHED Book Award Results
16th Annual Writer’s Digest
International SELF-PUBLISHED Book Award Results
Rita Dear received a Certificate of Participation
for Eutopian Destiny in the Mainstream/Literary Fiction category.
The Judge’s Rating - on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being the highest were:Plot – 4
Grammar – 5
Character Development – 5
Cover Design – 4
Question to the Judge: “What did you like best about this book?”
Judge’s Response: “Congratulations on a lovely book. I most enjoyed your characterization skills. Joe is a wonderful hero, strong, caring, inventive, touched by spirit. You give him a large cast of characters with which to interact, and he manages the relationships with all of them with love and intelligence. I would love to read more about this character, but then I wonder how you could actually pull that off because of his development in this book? That is beside the point of course. Not a criticism. It merely shows my involvement with the character that I want to know what he does next.”
Question to the Judge: “How can the author improve this book?”
Judge’s Response: “If such a thing is possible, I felt you had too much plot, too many complications. I devoured the first half of the book, enjoyed it immensely. Your writing flows smoothly and draws the reader into the story.”1..... “I see you have many more books either planned or completed. I also commend you for your goal of creating books that are compelling without being nasty. Congratulations on this first in the series. It’s a good start.”
1 Author’s note: The Judge suggested a simpler plot and provided some examples. Since I could only submit one book, the Judge had no way of knowing that those multiple ‘complications’ resurface at various points in the rest of the series.
